top of page

The following stories were published in the Hillside Nest between 2005 and 2023.
 

What Ever Happened to Oneida Carmichael

             A fluid rainbow of young people, bouncing and bobbing on the sidewalk, approached Ben. He heard their calls and shouts, brash and bragging. “She was all dead and shit!”

            “Maybe not…I heard an ambulance coming,” a tired young woman in a white t-shirt and jeans shorts responded with new freshness.

            “You fulla shit, Starla.” A tall young man directed his attack at the Starla one with a pointed bob of his head down to her taut shortness.

            She demurred and said almost to herself, “Love is love.”

            It was lunchtime. Ben was walking from his Washington Square office to his favorite spot on the Westside – the new waterfront park at the site of the old Christopher Street Pier.  His name was Ben now. When he first met Oneida Carmichael, he called himself Benjamin. He remembered this as he looked up at Oneida’s high rise apartment building. Ben reached the edge of the crowd and worked his way through it to get a look. There was Oneida Carmichael dead on the ground. Her body, in a finely tailored suit, was a tangled wreck, and her long, brown hair was splayed out on the concrete in a rapidly growing pool of blood.

            Ben did not linger there too long. He thought perhaps he should say something to someone about something, but he took this confusion down to the Hudson River and sat down on a bench. What happened.

            He thought he had been in love with her, but, though it took him forever to admit it, he knew that Oneida felt nothing that way toward him. He was a sociology professor, and Oneida was a grad student in social work. He oversaw her practicum, or at least he did in the beginning. It had been weeks since Oneida had kept a meeting with him. He blamed it on his feelings – though he had never approached her with them – spilling over into their professional relationship. His feelings toward women were always blameworthy, and so he was alone.

            He took her out to dinner twice. He experienced a major letdown the second time when Oneida told him that her name was given to her by her father because of his fondness for his summers on the lake with the same name. Ben had been sure that she took her name from the Iroquois nation tribe with the same name. It wasn’t the same. Her dark hair and eyes lost their ancient, exotic appeal. Only the mystery remained. He knew only fragments of her past. She wore the same turquoise earrings everyday – a gift from her mother, not a Native American heirloom. Her parents were wealthy, old school – they had benefited greatly from New York capitalism so their children would have careers in public service. They were good people and Oneida was a good girl. Oneida was their only child who wanted to be a fashion designer but became a social worker. Her parents were proud and set her up with a generous allowance in a fine apartment on the river in the West Village in one of those new high rises that disturbed the skyline and disrupted the sight line for those less fortunately positioned inland. Ben was impressed with Oneida’s dedication to her work. Her course work was stellar, but she really shined on the job. Despite her privileged upbringing, Oneida seemed most at home on the street. Ben thought she moved almost too easily from the protected confines of her luxury apartment to her clients’ rough and tumble world of drugs and prostitution.

            The agency Oneida worked for had its offices in a church basement on Hudson Street a few blocks below Christopher. Her clients were referrals from the criminal justice system, mostly young women arrested for prostitution whose problem was mostly drugs. Oneida’s job was to offer counseling and referrals to appropriate agencies. She loved her job and somehow felt more at home amidst the troubled young women than she did high up in her apartment. She seemed to dwell in two different universes – the luxurious but still cold, austere one provided by her parents and the provocative, tumultuous and slightly dangerous church basement.

            Then, for Oneida, there was Starla, a young, compelling, beautiful, confused and confusing reason for Oneida to go to work each day. Starla spent her time between her mother’s place in East New York and various crash locales in lower Manhattan. Starla dabbled in prostitution, just enough for alcohol, cocaine and maybe some food. Like Oneida once did, Starla dreamed of being a fashion designer. She often brought her sketches to their sessions. Starla and her cohorts – a rag-tag jumble of street kids, gay and straight, male and female and tranny – saw themselves as a future fashion consortium, designing, marketing, modeling their street fashion creations to an awaiting world. It was a dream that would blossom in woozy, sun-filtered mornings and fade in drug-addled, wasted nights. Starla disrupted Oneida. She brought forth feelings that cut through Oneida’s own enigma. No need to fuss over who she was. Identity fell away in the scorch and blaze of desire all its own.

            That summer morning Starla was wearing a tight white t-shirt and short cut-off jean shorts. Starla’s hair was long and full and played off her back. Her eyes reigned in shadowed sockets emanating early lines toward her temples and hair. She had a rounded gently puffed nose with nostrils that flared slightly with each breath. Her mouth was full and broad, her white teeth unburdened by her lifestyle. Starla’s thin shoulders and arms framed round, slightly sagging breasts, and, in a way that did not surprise or bother Oneida at all, Oneida could focus on just one thing – the way Starla’s white shirt slid back and forth against her braless chest making her nipples rise and poke. It was their sixth meeting in and as many weeks, and Oneida ended the mid-afternoon session by asking Starla out to lunch. She had crossed a line. For just an instant, questions flashed – Where was she? Who was she? Questions she would never be able to really answer again.

            Starla spoke animatedly through a lunch with wine which slid without hesitation into more drinks at a Hudson street bar. Oneida mostly gazed at Starla and smiled, laughed and asked an occasional question feigning a need to make some sense out of Starla’s preposterous, desperate life. Through more stories and more drinks, Starla’s gestures grew in size and began to catch Oneida’s hands and arms, and then her hair and face. Lost in this storm of expression, Oneida was barely surprised when Starla blurted out, “Do you get high?”

            Oneida fumbled with “I don’t know” and “Well, yeah, in college” and a smiling “What do you mean?” But it didn’t matter. Oneida was already willingly given to Starla’s direction, and so she was handing Starla fifty dollars and her address.

            “I’ll be there in twenty minutes,” Starla said over her shoulder, which it slid out of her top as she moved toward the bar door. Oneida felt full of excited nervousness as she paid the bill, gathered her things and hurried home.

            A half hour later, Starla was at Oneida’s apartment door. She came in quickly, hugged Oneida and set about preparing something with little plastic bags and one of those cracked glass pipes. Oneida poured them each a glass of wine. Soon thick, acrid smoke filled the air and then filled Oneida’s lungs. They threw off their clothes and moved on each other – tongues and fingers swarming everywhere. Oneida’s knees buckled. Outside became inside. Inside Out. She had lost all bearings. Starla became all – warm, soft nose and mouth, tongue and a thousand fingers. Oneida exhaled and moaned, completely present, completely lost.

            Later, from a dream, Oneida found Starla at the edge of the bed. Starla finished buttoning her shirt and raised her head, flipping her brown hair back off her face and over her shoulder. “Love is Love…You got twenty dollas?”

            Oneida fumbled with sheets and hair. “Sure..let me get it.” She bent over the side of the bed, reaching at strewn clothing.

            Starla watched intently. “Love is Love.”

            When Starla had left, a jittery Oneida poured herself a glass of wine, drank it quickly, poured herself another and settled back in bed. In the window, there was still light in the sky and Oneida remembered that she was having lunch with her parents the next day. She set the glass down on the night stand and rolled over.

            Somewhere in the darkness, her buzzer was ringing. It was Starla, and Oneida let her up. Oneida handed Starla two twenties through the opening in the chain-locked door. “I’ll be back. Love is love.” Starla repeated as she scurried off. Oneida ran her fingers through her hair and she sat back down on the bed and stopped herself from wondering what she was doing and concentrated dizzily on what she wanted.

            Two hours later, Starla was back. Smoke and more smoke. Wine and more wine. Love and more love.

            Oneida’s eyes and brain opened at the same time. Who? Where? Memory crept in. She pulled the covers over herself and rolled over. Then suddenly. The time? Lunch?

            She fumbled, washed and dressed. She was all shaky and sick. She did not want to face her parents. Then a gagging, convulsion of nausea. Her mother’s earrings were gone and she had not had a chance to tell Starla that the phrase she kept repeating didn’t mean anything.

 

            Ben rubbed his face in his hands, sighed, got up and started to walk out onto the green-lawned park which stretched like a finger into the river. His imagination had no room for the trouble that lay in between a colonial Indian woman, a lake in upstate New York, a denizen of a West Village high rise, and a dedicated social worker. He only knew it was all a terrible waste.

Becky and David
 

   David was one of the first in his suburban neighborhood to switch from a gasoline burning leaf blower to an electric one. Al Skeppa had mocked David, calling him a “tree hugger,” but David felt good about his efforts to fight climate change. He and Becky recycled religiously and used metal, refillable water bottles, which Becky always carried, deliberately and proudly, high in front of her as she walked the ten feet from their front door to her car each morning.

   David bought a fifty-foot orange extension cord at Home Depot to go with his leaf blower. Don Sedoux, who lived next door and had no leaves on his emerald lawn, had recommended it, although when he did, David had struggled to hear him over the roar of Don’s sit-down lawn mower. The choice of that particular cord, though, was confirmed by Leslie Hoppa, who David encountered in the Home Depot parking lot when her car alarm had been going off for absolutely no reason for three hours. A passerby had googled “stuck car alarm” on his phone and discovered there was nothing that could be done about it unless the government barred dark skinned immigrants and cut taxes. David found Leslie leaning against her Mercedes and watching Instagram reels and oblivious to the shrill, intense sounds emanating from her shiny new car. “Oh, for real, get the orange fifty-footer,” she confirmed. A week later, Becky excitedly announced that Leslie had started a Go Fund Me page for herself because she needed a new car. 

   David trusted Don because he had tipped David off about Bitcoin, and even though David and Becky had lost thousands from their digital currency investment, Don had made a fortune as evidenced by his classy, pronounced lack of conspicuous consumption. Indeed, Don proudly shopped at Costco, shouting to David over the roar of a  pool vacuum, “A bargain is a bargain. It is what it is.”

   Becky and David loved their pool, especially Becky. For a while it had been a nuisance to clean - all that tree mess - but when Don cut down the forty foot mulberry tree that had lived on his property for eighty years longer than Don had and which always made a horrible blue-purple berry mess each summer, they got the idea to have the even bigger sugar maple tree on their side taken away. Once the trees were gone, they enjoyed their pool, but Becky was upset that she burned more easily now with no shade. But then, fortunately, Don tipped them off to a special on cases of sunblock that was running at Costco. Not wanting to be spotted shopping there, Don asked Leslie Hoppa, after he had finished making love to her in the back of her Mercedes, to pick some up for them. After that, the trees gone, her skin protected, Becky luxuriated in the pool, only bothered each time she dropped her phone in the water. Don dutifully replaced each ruined phone, and always wanting to keep Becky happy, he only timidly suggested that she not bring her phone in the pool, a suggestion unheeded as Becky’s aquatic Instagram photos received thousands of heart likes.

   Don loved his eco-friendly blower and never thought about how the electricity to run it was generated; it would have made him confused and uncomfortable. Once, though, when he was scrolling Facebook on his phone, next to but not in the pool where Becky was, he felt a vague sense of reassurance when he saw a picture of a giant array of solar panels in China. So, he shared it with Becky (on Facebook) and shared it to his own page. For some reason, Don Sedoux reacted to the post with an angry emoji.

   All was well in the neighborhood. All were content with the ease with which they dispatched with the unease generated by their screens by buying more stuff. The lawns and paved over and concrete yards were free of anything alive or once alive or never alive, free of any mush or swamp or smell, until Al Skeppa lost his mind.

   Al lived across the street, a paved over country lane where big Dodge Ram pickups, owned by people who used them mostly to carry their Costco loads of toilet paper and snacks, sat idling all day while their owners scrolled in oblivion from behind the wheel. Al had been regarded as just “slightly peculiar” for some time. He was a nice guy, super-friendly and fastidious in his lawn care. But he cut his grass - at least twice a week, unless it rained, then more times - wearing brightly colored, tight short shorts that looked like something seen on a basketball court in the early 1970s. But other than the strange garb, Al was exceedingly “normal.” Then one day, while talking with David and Don, each positioned in his pickup cab, Al asked, for the third time that week, “When is garbage picked up?” Then the next day, he asked again.           Some of the people in the neighborhood sometimes forgot when recycling was picked up, but no one would ever forget garbage pickup, which liberated the town’s consumers from their mountains of discarded stuff, purchased, sometimes surreptitiously, from the big box bargain stores and also online. David and Don grew concerned, and then everyone became alarmed when Al bought a tractor and started riding it up and down his driveway, trying to mow the pavement and sending small stones screaming through the air, one of which struck Marybeth Holderlaine in the head and left her blind and unable to walk. Al apologized to the Holderlaines, but the next day he was seen without his short shorts, carrying TVs - big ones, eleven in all - out of his house and onto the front lawn. Don asked him why, and Al informed him, surprisingly correctly, that trash pickup was that night. 

   There were many indiscretions that the residents of the town where Becky and David lived could overlook, but discarding perfectly good televisions, barely out of their big boxes, was intolerable. The police were called, and Al was taken away. Later they found the body of his badly beaten wife in the refrigerator. The townspeople were briefly shocked that something could go terribly wrong in their pristine paradise, but then later they felt okay.

   Summer came, and Becky and David opted for a staycation at home by their pool with their phones and electric powered tools, including a cordless pool vacuum they purchased from Amazon by mistake since David really enjoyed twisting and stretching and flipping his long extension cord all around the yard. He’d grown adept at whipping the thing behind him as he blasted even the tiniest of leaf fragments off his property until the wind invariably blew it back. One early morning, as David stretched the extension cord as far as it could go in order to blow a dead impatien flower that was malingering on the other side of the pool into Don’s yard, he heard a furious splashing in the pool. Unbeknownst to David, the fifty foot orange extension cord had wrapped around his beloved ten-thousand-dollar cockapoo, Flecka’s, neck and sent her hurtling into the pool where she floundered and then drowned. David was inconsolable for weeks over losing his beloved little friend, but Becky got over it. She had lost interest in Flecka just a few weeks after they had flown back from Phoenix where they had purchased her from a breeder they had found on Instagram.

   David moped and neglected his yard. The leaves began to accumulate, some even floated in the pool, pictures of which Becky posted with the caption, “Responsible husband wanted!” David’s prized electric Roundup sprayer, a gift from Leslie Hoppa, gathered dust in the garage as bees and fireflies began to appear in the yard. Becky was at her limit. She texted her husband who was well within earshot, “Great, now we have bugs. You are USELESS!”

   Don noticed the sudden drain on the electric current that powered the neighborhood when his new blender, violently mixing the smoothie recipe he had watched being executed on Tik Tok, suddenly slowed. He went to the kitchen window and saw a puff of smoke rising from Becky and David’s pool. 

   Becky’s electrocuted body was found floating next to an electric leaf blower attached to a long orange extension cord plugged into an outdoor outlet. David was found dead behind the driver’s seat of his Dodge Ram, whose engine still hummed inside the garage where countless unused electric power tools hung on the walls.

 

   Becky and David had gone to grade school together but drifted apart when they went to different high schools. Later, when they reconnected as undergrads at Franklin and Marshall majoring in Business Administration, they confessed their mutual grade school crushes: Becky said, “I liked you,” which meant a lot more than that and made nineteen-year-old David turn crimson.

   He blurted, “All I could think about was you.”

   “Wow.”

   That was it, that was enough. They married their mysterious childhood crushes to their young adult lust and committed to each other. They liked making plans, although they were also woefully unimaginative, and so they looked around - not far - and picked out the available plans offered by the world as they had become used to seeing it, a world with boundaries, the illusion of freedom, the illusion of choice, a comfortable place to live. Becky googled, “list of things to do in life” and found the following:

  1. Play

  2. College

  3. Career

  4. Marriage

  5. House

  6. Dog

  7. Kids

  8. Work

  9. Retire

   Becky added “10. Die,” which made them both laugh, albeit nervously, but then she deleted it. 

   After college, they attended one friend’s wedding after another and farmed ideas for their own, for which Becky’s parents spent lavishly. Big, cream-colored limousines shuttled the guests from the church to the reception and then to the hotel booked from top to bottom for Becky and David’s big day. In the backs of the limos, as they sat in traffic between stops, the chatter was the same: “This reminds me of Gelnda’s wedding.”

   “I know, right?”

   “I like how everyone in the wedding party looked exactly the same.”

   “And I like how all the men at the wedding are wearing the same-colored suits and have the same haircuts.”

   “And those brown shoes.”

   “Right?”

   “The women look nice like they did at Farla’s wedding.”

   “Exactly. They do.”

   From one bland, off-white limo to another, the same confirming conversations, everyone engaged in building each other’s comfortable, rationalized space, within which everyone convinced themselves they were not only special and unique, but also safe. They were horribly wrong.

   Stepping out of one of the oversized automobiles, Tony Lind, whom, according to Becky, David had spent too much time with as a freshman smoking weed, remarked, “Look at that blue sky. It’s a miracle how blue our atmosphere and oceans are.”

   His companion, Lisa Maddox, exclaimed, “Awesome,” but she was referring to her friend Donna Feldor, who emerged from her limo having positioned a white flower from her bridesmaid’s all white bouquet in her faux blonde hair.

   And so it went… 

   For Becky and David, the house next to Don Sedoux and across the street from Al Skeppa soon followed. They decided to put off having a child until after they had travelled, but they never did either. They changed their plans after Becky read an article that had been shared with her on Instagram that explained that it was better to travel after retirement when you would have more money and are able to travel in greater comfort. The article didn’t address having children, appealing to a young, rich millennial demographic not interested in diapers. David read the same article when Leslie Hoppa, with whom David started an affair, shared it with him. It enabled him to justify his time with her, “Yeah, I got married too young and still have things to get out of my system. I’ll travel later when I am more settled.”

Leslie was hardly confused, “I understand.”

   Those things from David’s system never made it to Becky who remained childless from year to year, but her confidence that she would someday be a mother never wavered even as she noticed she was thirty-five one morning in the pool when six hundred people wished her “Happy Birthday” on Facebook. This outpouring of sentiments inspired Becky to pull out their eighth-grade yearbook that night. She and David felt tinges of nostalgia over the various team sports photos, but they had trouble remembering most of the student photos. The written names had detached from the photographs. And they couldn’t remember who they were then either. They couldn’t remember playing or dreaming or staring in wonder at baby fish and robbins’ eggs or falling in love or the streams in the woods that eddied around rock islands before joining rivers and oceans.

  • X
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

©2025  by James Vantana and  James Dievler

All rights reserved

bottom of page